Yeah, currently if you download a challenging song, it's very likely going to be unfinished or just really badly done. It's a kinda sad state of affairs; we have this awesome site but users are discouraged to search for new stuff because everyone knows they're digging through a huge mountain of poop to find that gem or two. Not blaming anyone here, it's just the way things are – it's the same in sites that host guitar tabs. Now I suppose we have a consensus on two things: 1) Rating systems come with all sorts of issues 2) Moderation is too much hard work So my suggestion is: put up a section where (some) mods have hand-picked some really good customs. The important point is, it doesn't have to be fair. It doesn't have to include every good custom. It's only important that it doesn't include bad ones. No one has to work their assess off being the judges. Just add a song whenever you feel like it. Or you could make it a weekly thing. Or whatever. Then that part of the site would have some decent content, like if I download a custom from there, I can trust it has correct notes and decent tones. And if not then I can complain and get it out of there. It'd be awesome for discovering previously unknown songs to play, too. The rest of the site could be just as it is now. No one would have to feel bad. And the rest of the site could still be used to find (and improve?) customs on your favourite bands/tracks.