Rodman

@Mikson - thats already a very chalenging score, bravo - thx for kicking me. Especially it´s great to have scores to tackle witzhin the running week and not only 2 or 3 hours befor week change.
Dunno if i can get that one or will die trying...

the stony way without RR

hard hard hard

perfect ratings

better

Boy, what a song!!!! 8, exactly, yeah

such a cool song, didn´t listen to that for a long long time, 6 to 6.5, yes

hard one, clear 7, yes

well played, @Mikson - lead is yours i fear

i love the rain

Bo-yaaa

way better

+ lead

@diceslinger guitar, bass, vocals, no post recording effects whatsoever

Ok found time for a lil info. I though suggest you listen first, read later.
That was much fun again. There are some songs i really have in my brain accurately though not listening to them for years. That´s one of those. Right the moment i read we had to do that i was thinking i´ll make a very basic campfiry version guitarwise to remember (as you know was the reason to start the whole thing). So for a start i listened to the song once, bought the dlc, played the guitar parts, then looked at the chords from the "official" UG version and recorded a playthrough with my standard clean tone on my strat which made it to the recording. Added a very backgroundy urban kit drumline, recorded a simple bassline and had a lot of fun singing it a few times (i hope your ears don´t hurt too much), i couldn´t use any effects on vocals and instruments because when setting up the project on my Zoom R24 i chose 48kHz instead if 44.1, and when all was in  the box and i wanted to start adding a lil chorus on guitar "44.1 kHz only" popped up.... However ... sign from the gods or rookie mistake, so all i did was pan the guitar and bass on either sides and mixed the volumes... isn´t it insane how different that all sounds when you go cellphone/stereosystem/headphones. Thx for that choice, happy with the result, cannot waitr for your version.

Picture is from Mount Dobratsch, taken by my wife last week on a Ski tour, blurred vision is caused by Sahara Sand that has been blown here all the way - oh i wish i had been there for that view!

Rod.

a hard 5, yeah - you master that, you jump to adv

what a cool week, 3 yeah

i´ll be back for those fresh sounding guys

hah! what a cool song! 8, exactly

not easy, but waaay cooler to play than on guitar for me

i think i´d go 7 here, it´s so un6

just lovely

8 for me - the ending section of the solo is way fast and 9, but thats only like 2 seconds

such a cool song - i recommend the CDLC from @Nacholede of the whole album (!) to anyone, an hour of playing fun all paths

7, yeah

4 hours ago, Orkkongen said:

Good answers. My wondering was a kind of asking, not to be taken as complaining. But I was frustrated, because the to first songs were so rather easy, and my own level so damn far from my level.

My complaining of the slides has nothing to do with the organizers. It's just annoying, like when people complain about Drop D not being recognized (that I seldom have problems with).

I think you are right, that the The Gold was 6/8, but it was not noted in 6/8, but rather 6/4, meaning the (small) lines were on the 1st, 3rd and 5th note and so on (the semiquavers/8th notes), while it should have been on 1st, 4th etc. It helped me a lot, when I began listening more. One of my strenghs is to read notes and play rhythms (based on the notes), so when it's of (visually) I get it wrong. But now it's so last week.

But yes, you have a point with different strengths and weaknesses. Sometimes I print a note-version to get a visual overview...
I am a long way from playing with a pick. Never really learned it.

I think that The Reincarnation of... is more simple.  in many ways. But it could have to do with the fore mentioned strengths and weaknesses. Out of curiosity it could be nice to know what others think of a comparison of those two songs.

Discussion about the diff votes is always welcome, keep those coming.
Good answers @jellisjenius