This comes from the discussion over at http://customsforge.com/topic/1470-the-need-to-separate-good-cdlc-from-unfinishedbad-one/

 

Basically this is a list of guys willing to commit some of our time to testing CDLC and commenting our findings be it at the workshop pertinent to that CDLC, via PM and/or the google docs below, if you need anything tested let us know by posting here or via PM to any of us at the list below, PERSONALLY i preffer PMs that way i get a notification so yeah, also let us know if you would like to test CDLC, this is an open group and we are happy to get more guys to join just try to keep it relaxed and follow our example, cheers :).

 

COMPLETE LIST OF TESTED CDLC: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AqgJhtukD_LedE85eVg4V3E2TjlZZ0t0RFJnNlZSU1E&usp=sharing%C2%A0

 

 

GUIDELINES FOR TESTERS(this are suggestions but we would really appreciate any tester keeping close to them):

 

-If you plan to test CDLC on a constant or semi-constant basis please let Olorin or myself know(its much more convenient for us if you do it via PM, BTW) that way we will add you to the list.

-Its not a job, you can do it on your own speed but we do ask you to report your feedback in at least two places, 1) the CDLC/workshop post of that particular song and also the GOOGLE DOC(link up there).

-If you report feedback at the CDLC post please go as much in detail as you feel to but when posting feedback in the google doc please try to keep it short and simple, read the first feedbacks to see how we did it and take from that example.

-Also please be sure to post links to the particular file you are reviewing for clarity sake.

 

A little explanation on the google docs entries logic:

 

As you can see we have the basic information colums: Artist, Song, Testers, Link, Status and Feedback.

 

***Artist/Song: self explanatory, name of the artist and the particular song you tested.

***Testers: basically, US, you, whoever has valid feedback for the CDLC.

***Link: link to the CDLCDB/WORKSHOP/FILE you tested, try to keep them valid in case the autor of the CDLC changes something.

***Status: The current status of the TESTING DONE on the CLDC, NOT the status of the charter project/CDLC, i.e. if it needs more TESTING, if it has been fully tested or not, personally i manage 2 status, FULLY TESTED(which i color GREEN) and AWAITING TESTERS (means me or someone tested the CDLC but would also like for more people to give us feedback on that particular CDLC, specially if i/we didnt tested ALL the features in the song, for example i only tested the bass but no lead)

***Feedback: BASIC feedback, specially short comments that summarize your findings, feel free to go into more detail when posting in the particular CDLC entry at the database or workshop post.

For example: 

 

"Lead: good but tone is too muddy/overdriven, rhythm: good but a bit imprecise at the end, bass: great"

 

As you can see you give info on what and where needs work but you can go into waaay more detail at the post of that CDLC on the DB.

 

ALSO, i just added the "CHARTER" column, that way we can give credit to whoever charted the CDLC ;).

 

THANK YOU :).

 

 

TESTERS:

 

CrazyEddie (on weekends)

***************

JayEm

*********

Olorin

********

urworstknight

******************

xDatBoiSOBLE

*******************

Joe

*****

piepesado

**************

Firekorn

***********

 

EDIT (26,04,2014): Just a small notice, i havent run away haha, ive just been busy with work and will continue to be until the end of this month (april, 2014), i really want this small project to get serious enough to help the community while being relaxed and not stressfull specially for the rest of our team ;).

Your Download Link Doesn't lead to a CDLC, just dropbox Main "Getting Started" page

I don't know if we have any testers active, but if we do please have a look at this PC CDLC

 

https://www.dropbox.com/home?preview=Koichi-Korenaga_Let-Me-Go-Let-You-Go_v1_p.psarc

 

Arrangements for Lead, Rhythm, and a bonus Combo arrangement. All E flat standard.

 

Thanks for any help.

 

Edit:

 

Okay it should work now. Sorry about that.

 

still no link, i have some time on my hands if someone needs some testing.

Hi,

 

If this thread is still active, I've just finished my first two cdlcs and want to get opinions on them e.g. if they're too easy, too hard, bugged, etc.

They're original songs made by me so there's not really anything to compare them to. If the thread isn't still actve, could anyone who's willing try them and then pm me the feeback?

Also I didn't do anything with tones or DD so if you have any tips or suggestions please let me know

 

Thanks

 

1st Song: http://www.mediafire.com/file/atf53vm4d459f2s/Bad-Songs-LTD_No-Regrets_v1_p.psarc/file

 

2nd Song: http://www.mediafire.com/file/p5np5n3438ky7eo/BadSongsLTD_Kimi-ha-Ganbaru-Kai_v1_p.psarc/file

Hi, if you want any lead or rhythm PC CDLC testing just pm me links I'm on everyday, so feed back will prompt'ish.