Jump to content

Welcome to CustomsForge Forums
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. This message will be removed once you have signed in.
Login to Account Create an Account

Learn & Play Rocksmith!

Want to play the songs you love? Registration and the use of this website is 100% free.
The only thing you need is a legal copy of Rocksmith 2014 w/ a cable. Click here to buy it.
 
Having trouble logging in or registering? Please click "Support" below.


Announcements:

We need to reach half of our donation goal asap! click here to donate.

Join us on Discord | Facebook | Twitter | Patreon | Merch | Volunteer


Photo

Approved CDLC Filter

- - - - -

  • This topic is locked This topic is locked
87 replies to this topic

Poll: Would you like to see an Approved CDLC Filter? (445 member(s) have cast votes)

Would you like to see an Approved CDLC Filter?

  1. Voted Yes (391 votes [87.87%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 87.87%

  2. No (54 votes [12.13%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 12.13%

Vote

#1
Offline   Unleashed2k

Unleashed2k

    CustomsForge Founder

  • Administrator

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 851 posts
  • Unleashed2k
  • Unleashed2k#11323
  • Unleashed2k#1337
  • Location:Orlando, FL
  • XBOX:Unleashed2k
  • PSN:FWF_Unleashed2k

Steam Profile


                 

Donator

Hello, We are now taking votes on releasing an CDLC approved area.

mini-faq:

What does this mean?

If the votes equal "YES", we would launch a new CDLC area for APPROVED CDLC's only. This means the CDLC will have everything finished, and tested by the community.  This would include: Lead, Rhythm, Bass, Vocals, Custom Tones, Synced up, RR And optional DD. (NO issues)

(exception is if one of the Arrangement types isn't available for the song) ​Additionally, you would need the appropriate album artwork, title, and everything else

 

So like SA's old system, right?

Similar yes, but better executed. All of the "approved" CDLCs would have to be 100% finished, in the correct format, and at an appropriate host that won't delete the song in a week or month if not downloaded.

 

EDIT:

This is NOT going to a separate section! There will be three filters - approved, unapproved, and in progress. The default will be to show all customs, but you can filter if you would like to see only approved customs. It will be integrated within our current search.


"Just remember: when something breaks, kick it as hard as you fucking can"

-Trent Reznor
Support Me (Via Patreon)


#2
Offline   MisterDC

MisterDC

    Expert Guitarist

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 105 posts
  • Location:Sweden

Finally, I vote yes!



#3
Offline   Mad_Duck

Mad_Duck

    Hardcore Guitarist

  • Donator
  • PipPipPip
  • 98 posts
  • Location:Canuckistan

It appeared my follow up question might have gotten lost in chat.
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]I was wondering what method you were thinking of using to keep things from going sour like it did elsewhere.[/font]
 
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]So things like:[/font]
Could you elaborate on the planned approval process?
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]How many "votes" are needed to give a nod for approval?[/font]
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]Who gets to vote?[/font]
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]Will 'approvers' be named?[/font]
etc.


md_sig-e1431714006358.jpg


#4
Offline   snowdog

snowdog

    Day One Donator

  • Donator
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 236 posts
  • Location:Tottenham (aka Beirut), North London

Donator

Sounds good to me!  :mrgreen:



#5
Offline   Unleashed2k

Unleashed2k

    CustomsForge Founder

  • Administrator

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 851 posts
  • Unleashed2k
  • Unleashed2k#11323
  • Unleashed2k#1337
  • Location:Orlando, FL
  • XBOX:Unleashed2k
  • PSN:FWF_Unleashed2k

Steam Profile


                 

Donator

It appeared my follow up question might have gotten lost in chat.
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]I was wondering what method you were thinking of using to keep things from going sour like it did elsewhere.[/font]
 
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]So things like:[/font]
Could you elaborate on the planned approval process?
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]How many "votes" are needed to give a nod for approval?[/font]
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]Who gets to vote?[/font]
[font="'Trebuchet MS', sans-serif;"]Will 'approvers' be named?[/font]
etc.

If the vote is a yes (looks to be that way) we will elaborate on everything before going ahead with it.
Approvers will be named, we still have to code and figure out how to do an approval system, and if we should wait for search3 or not.


"Just remember: when something breaks, kick it as hard as you fucking can"

-Trent Reznor
Support Me (Via Patreon)


#6
Offline   UKLooney

UKLooney

    Touring Guitarist

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 566 posts
  • Location::- The Shire

 

 and at an appropriate host that won't delete the song in a week or month if not downloaded.

 

So I can use a paid for sendspace account?


All my customs can be found here :)


#7
Offline   The Troglodyte

The Troglodyte

    Ex-Staff Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 294 posts
  • Location:Middle Of Nowhere, Also Known As Wales

 

 

 and at an appropriate host that won't delete the song in a week or month if not downloaded.

 

So I can use a paid for sendspace account?

 

Don't use sendspace, it's in the rules.



#8
Offline   UKLooney

UKLooney

    Touring Guitarist

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 566 posts
  • Location::- The Shire

 

Don't use sendspace, it's in the rules.

 

 

No one is forcing you to use it?


All my customs can be found here :)


#9
Offline   Unleashed2k

Unleashed2k

    CustomsForge Founder

  • Administrator

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 851 posts
  • Unleashed2k
  • Unleashed2k#11323
  • Unleashed2k#1337
  • Location:Orlando, FL
  • XBOX:Unleashed2k
  • PSN:FWF_Unleashed2k

Steam Profile


                 

Donator

 

 

 

 and at an appropriate host that won't delete the song in a week or month if not downloaded.

 

So I can use a paid for sendspace account?

 

Don't use sendspace, it's in the rules.

 

I changed that rule, sendspace is allowed as long as a mirror is provided.


"Just remember: when something breaks, kick it as hard as you fucking can"

-Trent Reznor
Support Me (Via Patreon)


#10
Offline   The Troglodyte

The Troglodyte

    Ex-Staff Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 294 posts
  • Location:Middle Of Nowhere, Also Known As Wales

That as well.



#11
Offline   SrMouraSilva

SrMouraSilva

    Beginner Guitarist

  • Member
  • Pip
  • 29 posts
  • Location:Brazil

It would be interesting to some kind of honor for publishers with CDLCs approved. Something similar accounting of the amount of 'thanks'

 

In fact, until the count sent CDLCs would be cool. After all, (I think) these are the main focus of forum



#12
Offline   kamakazikilla

kamakazikilla

    The Loved One.

  • Member
  • Pip
  • 39 posts

alright... couple of things i mentioned in chat, but wanted it to get put up here so people can think on it a bit.

 

1. the idea of this is really good, makes sense, but should be further diversified IMO... let me explain

 

 - it's been explained that the approval hinges on hard factors such as the completeness of the chart in terms of instruments, this makes sense and is nice, but should be its own sub-category for a couple of reasons. those reasons are as follows.

 

2. reason list =p

 

 - lots of songs don't have all parts involved, or some people may not be able to find certain tabs or whatever. leaving only one particular instrument to be done. for the sake of completion, yes, you'd like them all, but if they aren't it shouldn't hurt your chances of being "approved"

 - some people may only care about one of the instruments in particular, why pseudo punish them for only doing what's relevant to them if they make it neat, playable, and well organized? other portions or even complete versions can be made my other people if they really want it, or a collaboration can be done in order to get all charts involved produced. things like vocals are a grey area in terms of their importance as well because they don't actually DO anything but fulfill the completeness effect. 

 

3. Important notes/considerations

 

 - people will put higher weight on "approved" songs in terms of quality and worthwhile-ness to download just because it's given a name

 - primary role of an "approved" section should (in my opinion) be to weed out the good from the okay or bad in terms of functionality of the song or accuracy of the song (such as bad tabs, bad sync, general unplayabilities)

 - having a specific section for total completeness is a grand idea, but it could function more effectively if it is only a portion of the approved area.

 

4. suggested alternative (minor changes really)

 

 -test on content as explained above, have a large list of accepted works, but show specifically in what areas they were approved (ie. multiple instruments) so on this list, you could say "oh, this song got approved even though it only has guitar and not bass, so we'll show that in our database somehow" 

 - make a list that shows what is available in each approved chart so people can work together to make it more complete and know that the platform they use to complete a song is a sound one

 - allow people to not do certain instruments, if somebody does a sweet job on guitar but doesn't like bass, just make sure the system can alert people to that information

 

5. DO have a section for total completeness within this list, but don't disqualify others from getting in based on completeness, it will make it much harder to find good charts and stratify the quality too much to be user friendly

 

everything mentioned above is my personal opinion, and you don't like it, sorry... i'm just explaining things in a way that i believe makes logical sense... if anyone wants clarification on a certain part, i'd love to give it to help!! i'm sure i've confused at least a couple of you with this... thanks!



#13
Offline   Mad_Duck

Mad_Duck

    Hardcore Guitarist

  • Donator
  • PipPipPip
  • 98 posts
  • Location:Canuckistan

This may relate to point 4,

 

What if in the Customs Database, The 'Parts' section (L/R/B/V) in addition to keeping the not done sections as greyed out, parts at a Workshop level were coloured bronze, parts that need tweaking get silver letters and parts that "sound like Jimi himself were playing" get gold/diamond sections.

 

Example: (totally made up, if you've released song X and are now crying because I'm saying it's bad, its not you, it's me)

I look through recent posts in the database and see that B.B. King "Every day I have the blues" is fresh out of someone's workshop and is in the database listed as:

 

[L] coloured gold - (it's accurate and it's gotten (~5) votes

[R] coloured black/silver - (released, but only a vote or 2 for approval so far, maybe in the song thread, someone has commented tone/bends aren't quite right yet, and author mentions plans to fix it)

[B] coloured grey - (I have a bass tab, and am confident and willing to chart it, so offer to do that part and send it to the original CDLC'er for co-credit or no credit or whatever.)

[V] X or [N/A] - (pretend it's an instrumental and no lyrics exist, so song could be 'Approved' without needing this category filled)

 

I think as a partial solution, it could get more people involved who wouldn't otherwise.

example: someone who loves lyrics but has no confidence with guitars could quickly skim through the list and find songs to contribute to by learning to chart the lyrics, which would leave more time for guitar charters to chart.

 

 

EDIT: append an [A] part for Album art (maybe rate the metadata here like Artist/Title/Album Cover are correct, and display correctly in game - there are a few songs that sort weird from capitilisations, etc)


md_sig-e1431714006358.jpg


#14
Offline   raynebc

raynebc

    Guitar God

  • Rocksmith Custom Developer

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,906 posts

So I can use a paid for sendspace account?

Don't use sendspace, it's in the rules.

A paid sendspace account should allow for a direct download (no ads), no waiting for the download to start and no age limits (unless the paid account itself expires). That addresses all the reasons that people don't like SendSpace, I don't know why it wouldn't be acceptable.

#15
Offline   SmellyOrc

SmellyOrc

    I <3 Lyric Sustain

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 451 posts

I've never had ads on sendspace, nor did i ever have to wait unless there was already a download in progress. I think that latter problem still exists for non-paying users. Also, sendspace is SLOW.



#16
Offline   wynterwolf

wynterwolf

    Beginner Guitarist

  • Member
  • Pip
  • 32 posts
  • Location:Apple Valley, MN

My concern is for the less popular songs.  Songs that are hard to play, or are by bands that most people don't listen to.  They'll tend to never get approved because they lack traffic.  This leads to needing testers who are motivated to test these songs.  How does a more obscure song get some recognition?  How does a charter who puts a ton of time into an obscure song get a song approved and get the recognition?

 

And I don't have answers for it either.  I just like more obscure music and I want to see those songs getting charted too.  Just a thought, really, for consideration.


Ubuntu Studio FTW

http://ubuntustudio.org/


#17
Offline   kamakazikilla

kamakazikilla

    The Loved One.

  • Member
  • Pip
  • 39 posts

in terms of obscurity, ALL SONGS THAT ARE SUBMITTED WILL BE TESTED... there's no way around that... it will be a lot of testing, but it's the only fair way to make it happen. there shouldn't be any issue on things getting approved based on how well liked the song is



#18
Offline   cstewart

cstewart

    Master Guitarist

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 342 posts
  • Location:Upstate NY

I'm pretty ambivalent about this whole thing.  There were plenty of songs on the other site that were perfectly playable and fun that for whatever reason never got "approved" by whoever did the approving.  If I want to know if a song is done well, I look at the comments.  If there are none, I just download it and take my chances.  If it has problems, I wait for the author to update it.  It probably helps that I don't download a ton of customs, only the ones I want to learn.

 

 I'm not against an approved section, but I don't see a compelling reason to be for it either.



#19
Offline   ForgeOn

ForgeOn

    Ex-Staff Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 294 posts

I would like to strongly second Mad_Duck's suggestion for a "Diamond/Gold/Silver/Bronze/Grey/X" badge system.

 

I wouldn't mind seeing an "approved" section but, for me, the best solution would be a simple search option to filter out "approved only/* also/* not" (or even better an option for selecting "silver and above"/"gold and above"/etc).

 

This way, while browsing the full list of available songs, higher quality customs can stand out (the benefit of an approved section) while avoiding a major downside that comes with having a separate and exclusive area: effectively hiding all unapproved songs by default to anyone who goes directly to the approved content area.

 

Another way to look at the badge option (vs the separate area) is that we would be marking excellent customs as "verified", rather than as "the only good ones".



#20
Offline   Alex360

Alex360

    Guitar God

  • Rocksmith Custom Developer

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,494 posts

Well don't talk about sendspace i think its wasting time we here sparing a free learning staff and not buying account on sand space for good dl speedno adsetc on sand space. About his System - I think we just need highlight those tested dlc like DD indicator (name it tested or approved whatever) and drop it away when new version is out (cause its  not testedapproved yet).

 

BTW i don't like to put DD in songs because it was bad idea from Ubi and I think its rediculous to play some kind of "twinkle twinkle little star", while in songs you need to play a lot more - this is a learning software, hello...