Rating CDLC + other suggestions

[Toopee]

Hi gang,

 

Sorry, I suppose that topic has already been discussed but I wasn't able to find anything.

I was just thinking it would be quite useful if we were able to check the overall quality of DLCs by having a rating system.

Maybe using different criteria, fidelity to the original track, tuning, audio quality, etc. + overall

 

Another thing in the same idea could be difficulty, either selected by the CDLC maker of the community.

 

Also, could be nice to have the information on the source used to make the CLDC (official tabs, amateur tabs on the web, personal interpretation...)

 

And finally, I realized uploading my first CDLC that I couldn't select different tuning for the different tracks (in my case, guitar is in D standard and Bass in Drop D) it's just a detail, but well, won't hurt mentioning it :)

 

Have a nice day \o/

 

[firekorn]

You might not have search for it too hard :

 

http://customsforge.com/topic/36714-possible-idea-for-cdlc-efficiency/?hl=rating

http://customsforge.com/topic/12117-new-rule-please-test-your-cdld-before-you-upload-it/?hl=quality%20control

http://customsforge.com/topic/27108-personal-indicatorsign-for-disliked-cdlc/?hl=rating+system

http://customsforge.com/topic/1470-the-need-to-separate-good-cdlc-from-unfinishedbad-one/?hl=rating%20system

 

There's quite a good read and there's probably a few topic missing.

 

TL, DR : Quality control is something we (CF) think off but it's not something easy to pull off and it can easily do more harm than good so for now it's open bar and you'll find everything.

[Toopee]

Fair enough. Guess I'll have to learn exactly how that search widget works.

That being said, my other suggestions remain.

 

Thanks for the links ;)

 

 

Ceci dit j'ai vraiment cherché.